If you've hung around my journal for a while, you may have heard me talking every so often about the Classic Doctors as women - what they'd be like, how that'd change their storylines if at all, how girl!One and Polly would totally team up to tease Ben, etc. But when I think of them, I would always imagine a feminized version of the actors who portrayed them, not a different actress. And that got me thinking: Who would I pick to portray each Doctor, if I were to pick from among the fine ladies of British drama?
I turn the question to you: if you were recasting the Classic Doctors with actresses (from any era, not necessarily just those from the 60's, 70s, and 80s), who would you pick?
Tragically, my knowledge of British actresses is somewhat lacking, so I have only a few ideas. For some reason, Cherie Lunghi strikes me as a really good girl!Two, especially after seeing her in Horatio Hornblower. She has that mischeviousness about her, that sense of fun and energy, and she does the stealth!mockery really very well. Plus, there's something about her eyes. I don't know. It'd be difficult to make her look properly "cosmic hobo", but I think she could pull it off.
( It's very hard to find pictures of her looking anywhere near floppy, though. )Also, girl!Three would be Joanna Lumley. I do not know why I am so certain. Maybe because I've seen her in so much 70s gear; maybe because she shares Pertwee's pechant for comically huge sunglasses in her publicity photos. Or maybe because I just got a mental picture of Lumley swordfighting Roger Delgado, nicking his lunch, and then giving him a flirty little pout when she throws his sword back. It was beautiful.
( Also, she's already played a Doctor, so it works out nicely. )I'm tempted to cast girl!One as Maggie Smith but I do believe that'd be typecasting.
( But here's a picture just because she's lovely. And I still think she'd be a good One. )So, who would your girl!old-school!Doctors be? Why? Pictures, explanations, and discussion are highly encouraged!