stunt_muppet: (busy posing)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] stunt_muppet at 08:53pm on 25/03/2008 under , ,

I call it meta but really it's whining.

Since my mother retains an inexplicable love for CSI: Miami (probably because she never saw the earlier seasons and doesn't believe me when I tell her how superior they are in every way to Season 6), my family of course watched the first post-strike episode. It was not "Sharked!", and thus failed to meet my expectations.

I ended up introducing my mom and dad to the term "Shades of Justice" when we did. Dad was amused; Mom still thinks I'm a freak for doing things like naming Horatio's sunglasses and yelling at the characters when they're stupid. Also, Mom insists that Miami really is that brightly-colored and sunny. I don't believe her. 

As for the actual episode...well, it wasn't bad. Okay, actually, it was bad - the motive for the murder was flimsy and the MO was so impossibly convoluted it made no sense.

If the baseball player's friend was so determined to get the stripper out of the way before she could humiliate him, why didn't he just strangle her in a bathroom somewhere and dump her body? Or shoot her as she went home from work? All of those would have been so much less complicated than the remote-triggered gun turret, not to mention less conspicuous and with much less chance for error. Oh, not to mention the gun turret was set to kill her in public, which would have raised an immediate outcry. If he'd disposed of her quietly somewhere else, she might not have been found for days. 

I could have bought the motive if the MO wasn't so ridiculous. I buy that kind of thing coming from Hodges, okay, writers? He's a science geek. He'd do something like that. Not from a baseball player.

But the thing is, this episode was sort of at the Season 6 Baseline of Suck. It wasn't especially bad, it was just...default for Season 6. Average. Unfortunately, 'average' for Season 6 isn't very good.

Oh, and there was one particular scene that made me hiss and spit with loathing and docked the episode a million zillion points in my personal tally:
Dimly-lit fetishistic "lesbian" sex from two characters who weren't actually lesbian. There is very little I loathe more than this in a television program. Because, of course, the only reason a woman would ever act sexually toward another woman is for the benefit of a male voyeur. What's that you say? Women can have sexual preferences and orientations without catering to the wants and needs of men? Bah! What rubbish are you talking now? Everyone knows that women are objects for men's sexual gratification no matter their orientation.

Seriously, I could almost understand this kind of thing in porn, where the whole point is for the viewer to get off anyway, but the fact that it's completely okay to show fetishistic fake lesbians on a network TV program now - legitimizing this kind of exploitation - just disgusts me in so many ways.

On a less-feminist note: If male viewers get fake lesbians to oogle at, I want fake gays. Seriously, writers. I DEMAND MANSEX. The blurry heterosexual hookups aren't gonna cut it anymore. I would have been content with them, normally and by content I mean annoyed and fed up, but you guys just had to up the ante. 

Conclusion: mansex. If it hasn't happened in two weeks, tersely-worded letters will be headed your way.

*sigh* I feel better now.

Anyway, there was little to note on the character front, except apparently there's some sort of conflict between Eric and Ryan that appears to have come from nowhere but will probably shuffle off into a plot hole and never show up again.

But enough about that. What I really want to talk about is next week's trailer.

So...apparently, Our Intrepid Hero is being "extradited to Brazil for murder", to quote the trailer. Oh, stop wringing your hands; he won't be convicted. This isn't the sort of show that'd cycle out its main character (though it'd be interesting if it was). 

No, mostly I just want to throw confetti and serve celebratory cake, because it's about time we addressed the fact that the do-gooder, guilty-conscience copper we've been following around for six seasons has, in fact, committed murder - revenge murder, no less. Granted, Horatio's been going to increasingly morally iffy places this season - blackmail and bribery, for starters - so perhaps, maybe, the writers are finally going to abandon the Horatio Is Always Right About Everything Ever mantra that they repeated incessantly throughout Season 5. I'm not putting money on it or anything, but it is a possibility.

Because the fact is that he did commit murder, and even if he isn't convicted he's going to have to confront that in a tral. Now, my knowledge of the Brazilian legal system hovers at zero, but I'm assuming there are still lawyers and judges and juries of one's peers involved? There are all sorts of ways he could fail to be convicted. Equivocal or inconclusive evidence, for a start; maybe there aren't enough prints on the murder weapon to prove who wielded it, or because there are no witnesses the jury can't be certain that the killing was not in self-defense. Or the jury could acquit him for their own inscrutable, jury-like reasons. Or (and this is more likely) the prosecuting attorneys and judges will be moustache-twirling villains and all charges will be dropped and Horatio will head home free and clear again. Whatever. But if he's going to go to trial on the matter, he's either going to have to a) confess to murder (and thus be convicted and sentenced) or b) add perjury to his lengthening list of moral failings.

I'm convinced it'll be the latter, since he didn't seem inclined to confess to his crime after he committed it, and he presumably never confessed to his father's death, but that opens up this whole other can of worms. Looking at it in black and white, how are we supposed to take him seriously as someone who's all about seeing justice done and punishing the guilty if his moral code conveniently doesn't apply to himself? The answer, of course, is that he's a human being, and all but the most saintly human beings tend to become less principled when faced with the prospect of their own punishment, particularly if that punishment entails possible life imprisonment. Having him perjure himself on the stand might just be good for his character; it'll humanize him, make him crucially less than perfect in a way that we haven't seen since Season 4, possibly even Season 3 (no, the killing of Riaz and the wanton 'self-defense' killings of Season 5 and 6 don't count. Why? Because the show was very clearly on his side then; the writers went out of their way to justify his actions, thus keeping up his 'perfect' image in the face of morally wrong decisions.)

Of course, one could argue that the murder of Riaz was a critical step down the slippery slope for Horatio. Most of his morally dodgy actions come in Seasons 5 and 6, and while I highly suspect that this is lazy writing as much as anything, there might be some point to it if you squint hard enough. Committing murder that he considers justified (a feeling he might not be familiar with, considering his guilt over his father) might finally push him over some kind of edge, forcing him to realize that he can't live up to his own moral standards - or even to the law. Which casts in a whole new light many of the people he's trying to arrest, doesn't it? They think they're justified too. 

Not that I think Our Intrepid Hero is about to plunge into a life of lawlessness, mind you - just that he's finally got to cede the moral high ground and he's not adjusting to that too well. :D

Gosh, it's been some time since I've engaged in tl;dr Miami meta. Felt kind of good, it did. :D Of course, I'm sure I'll be disappointed with the upcoming story arc, but it doesn't hurt to contemplate.

Back to That Doctor Who Fic What Stubbornly Refuses To Be Written. *grumble* Someone tell me why I keep trying to write Liz Shaw when her voice is so frustratingly elusive.

(also, is it bad that I missed Diet Mountain Dew and Honey Bunches of Oats with Almonds while I was at home?)
Music:: "I Don't Feel Like Dancing" - Scissor Sisters
location: hidey-hole again
There are 13 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] biichan.livejournal.com at 02:30am on 26/03/2008
Huh. My only exposure to CSI: Miami sadly is from a fic where Horatio is actually Six in disguise. Is, um, this an actually plausible characterization? (For a loose definition of plausible?)
 
posted by [identity profile] stunt-muppet.livejournal.com at 03:05am on 26/03/2008
You know, I was about to say no, but this fic actually makes a bizarre sort of sense. I could imagine Horatio as Six dialed way down. Horatio's got a huge guilt complex that I can't see in TV!Six (I can't speak for Audio!Six), but they do have a similar flair for the dramatic. And the tendency towards slightly odd speech mannerisms.

...Wow. Never would have thought of that, but now I'm wondering how I missed it. This is going to make rerun season a bit odd.
 
posted by [identity profile] gorengal.livejournal.com at 04:13am on 26/03/2008
See, that's exactly why I stopped watching it last season.

PS - I've been to Miami. It looked old and sad, definitely not shiny/pretty.
 
posted by [identity profile] stunt-muppet.livejournal.com at 04:23pm on 26/03/2008
I keep meaning to stop watching, but maybe it's trainwreck syndrome, maybe it's some misguided hope that one day I'll wake up and this show will be good again, I don't know, but I sort of forgot to stop.

I'm not surprised. Nothing's ever as pretty as it is on TV.
 
posted by [identity profile] widdledragon.livejournal.com at 04:22am on 26/03/2008
Drama over fishnet, that was so lame.

Mom says our plot would be better if they got it in the face.
 
posted by [identity profile] stunt-muppet.livejournal.com at 04:33pm on 26/03/2008
Yes, yes it was. And then the whole veil subplot went absolutely nowhere.

Bah. Our version's still better. And if the guy gets sharked in the face we can attach that "based on a true story" tag to it! You know, what with the manta ray and all.
 
posted by [identity profile] sterling-sky.livejournal.com at 05:39am on 26/03/2008
Hey, a meta of a Miami ep I actually watched! 'Cept I kept falling asleep. But I saw parts of it. And yeah, I had a WTF moment too. I mean, surely Miami is crawling with real lesbo strippers, so why bother with fake ones? ;)

That oughta be in the World Series' new anti-steroids pamphlet - "Don't juice! Your shrunken penis will make your wife turn to fake lesbian strippers!"

I am so getting hate mail from Miami fans, baseball fans, and the Human Rights Commission right now. :P

Also, your demand for mansex made me LOL.
 
posted by [identity profile] stunt-muppet.livejournal.com at 04:38pm on 26/03/2008
Bah, you didn't miss anything. Didn't make much more sense for the people who stayed awake the whole time. :(

Also, I imagine that your pamphlets would be much more effective than whatever they've got now. XD I'm sure that's the real reason Wifey requested a dance - she was already sexually frustrated past the point of endurance.

And hey, I'm all for equal opportunity objectification. :D
 
posted by [identity profile] viralmancer.livejournal.com at 07:17pm on 27/03/2008
And if you listen really closely, you can hear the sound of a thousand writers screaming in fear at the mere suggestion of tersely-worded letters.
 
posted by [identity profile] stunt-muppet.livejournal.com at 07:55pm on 27/03/2008
Oh, they will be very tersely-worded letters. They shall employ rhetoric and scathing wit like unto which the studio inbox has never seen.

< /self-importance>
 
I could have bought the motive if the MO wasn't so ridiculous.
*Ugh...I honestly didn't even think about the MO until you pointed it out. Now I can't think about anything except how ludicrously complicated his plan was. Well, that and how fantastic it would be if Hodges actually did orchestrate a murder by remote-controlled bullet fire. Maybe his invention of the board game was a subtle warning sign.

*Ryan and Eric never stop having conflicts. Actually, I'm a little impressed that they may be the only two coworkers in crime drama who don't fit into the One Big Happy Family mold.

*Oh, man, you've introduced so much POTENTIAL for amazing things in the next episode...I am going to be crushed with disappointment when none of them even come close to fruition.
 
*My theory is that the writers thought up the remote-control gun turret for "You Kill Me" and thought it was just soooo awesome that they had to use it again, even if it didn't make any sense in context.

Seriously, anyone who can actually think up something as intricate as Hodges did in "You Kill Me" is not to be trusted. ;)

*Actually, I'm a little impressed that they may be the only two coworkers in crime drama who don't fit into the One Big Happy Family mold.

Good point. I guess that'd sort of passed out of my mind now that Ryan's stopped being his early-season screwup self.

*Frankly, so far as the next episode is concerned, I'm setting myself up for improbably villainous judges and attorneys, kangaroo courts, and Horatio coming off scot-free once again. If I keep my expectations low, I can't be disappointed, can I? :(
 
posted by [identity profile] rainbowstevie.livejournal.com at 04:21pm on 29/03/2008
I think it's a mark of how ludicrous (I like that word) the show has gotten that I first read "kangaroo courts" as "kangaroos IN courts," and wasn't even fazed.

Although a tiny little part of me can't help hoping it's this season's No Man's Land/Man Down.

July

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
        1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26 27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31